Future of Dacorum Borough Council uncertain as county chief warns ministers

The future of local government services in Hemel Hempstead and the wider Dacorum area remains uncertain as ministers face warnings that they have "one last chance" to get council reorganisation right.

The Government withdrew its decision to replace Hertfordshire's existing county, district and borough councils with four new unitary authorities last month, leaving the future structure of local government in the area undecided.

Dacorum Borough Council. Photo: Google Street Viewplaceholder image
Dacorum Borough Council. Photo: Google Street View

Under the original plans, Dacorum and St Albans would have been brought together under a new unitary council, responsible for services currently provided by Dacorum Borough Council, St Albans City and District Council and Hertfordshire County Council in those areas. However, the decision was withdrawn on October 29, with alternative proposals to divide Hertfordshire into two or three unitary authorities also remaining under consideration.

The uncertainty comes as the chairman of the influential County Councils Network (CCN) warns that trust in the Government's handling of reorganisation is on the verge of "completely evaporating". Councillor Sean Matthews, who is also the Reform UK leader of Lincolnshire County Council, has questioned whether the Government's review is focused on reaching better decisions or strengthening its legal position.

In his speech at CCN's annual conference in Buckinghamshire on Monday (November 16), Councillor Matthews will welcome the decision to reconsider previous proposals but raised concerns about the process.

He will say: "The Government are right to withdraw previous decisions and look again.

"But as we stand today, the recent announcement provided little reassurance that the process will be robust, fair and transparent." Councillor Matthews will add that there is a growing concern that the review was less about reaching better decisions and more about strengthening the Government's legal position, ending previous challenges and avoiding disclosure of ministerial advice.

He will warn that trust in the Government's handling of reorganisation had already been severely damaged and was at risk of "completely evaporating".

"The government has one last chance to get this right," he will say.

"But that requires a transparent process and decisions based on evidence rather than political or legal expediency."

The reorganisation process has proved contentious in several parts of England, with at least eight councils either launching or considering legal challenges over the proposed boundaries of new authorities.

In October, the Government withdrew decisions covering Hertfordshire and eight other areas.

Earlier decisions affecting Essex, Hampshire, Norfolk and Suffolk are also under review.

The Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government has said the review is intended to ensure the process is robust and supports the Government's wider plans to reform local government.

Communities Secretary Angela Rayner defended her approach when questioned by the Commons Housing, Communities and Local Government Committee last week.

She said: "The reason I took the pause was because when I make decisions, I want to know I am making the right decisions and that means I have got to have the information."

She added: "LGR was always going to be contentious and it was always going to be litigated, let's be honest."

The Government expects to announce further provisional decisions early 2027, although it has not confirmed when Hertfordshire's proposals will be considered.

Elections to new authorities are planned for May 2028, with the councils due to take responsibility for services on April 1, 2029.

Until then, DBC and HCC will continue delivering their existing services.

News you can trust since 1858
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice